English 11 and English 10
Today we will look at persuasive/argumentative writing.
ARGUMENTATION – attempts to convince through logic.
Argumentation takes two opposite forms, deduction and induction.
Deduction accepts a general principle as true, then applies it to specific cases.
Major premise: All men are mortal.
Minor premise: Socrates is a man. GOOD ARGUMENT
Conclusion: Socrates is mortal.
BAD Major premise: Progress is good.
ARGUMENT Minor premise: The automobile represents progress. Conclusion: The automobile is good.
The problem with deduction is that we cannot always agree on premises.
Induction is the opposite of deduction. It first observes particular cases, then from them formulates a general rule.
After a summer in the factory Joan thought she could afford a car, so the week before school began she bought a sporty red three-year-old japanese model. Speeding around town with the stereo turned up was so much fun that she didn’t mind the $350-a-month payments. But when the insurance company hit her for $2500 as a new driver, her savings took a dive. Each month she found herself paying $100 for gas and $150 for parking. A fall tune-up set her back $200, and new tires $400. Then came the repairs: $250 for brakes, $350 for a clutch, and $225 for an exhaust system. In desperation Joan took a part-time job selling shoes. That helped her bankbook but took her study time. Two weeks after exams, holding a sickly grade report in her hand, Joan decided to sell the car. Nobody could have told her to, since, like most people, she likes to make up her own mind. But the long string of evidence did the teaching: now Joan knows, through induction, that as a student she cannot afford a car.
PERSUASION – attempts to convince through emotion.
Major techniques:
Word choice: Is an oil spill an “incident,” an “accident,” a “mistake,” a “crime” or an “environmental tragedy”? Writers tend to choose the term that reflects their feeling and the feeling they hope to encourage in the readers.
Example: An attempt to show old people as active may be helped by the example of your grandmother who skis.
Repetition: Intentional repetition can build feeling.
Hyperbole (exaggeration): This is used in humorous pieces. “Man You’re a Great Player!” – Gary Lautens.
Analogy and figures of speech: Analogies, comparing one thing with another from a different category (a monster with the forest industry), and their shorter cousins similes and metaphors, are powerful tools of persuasion.
Irony: “My Body Is My Own Business” – Naheed Mustafa
Appeal to authority or prestige: We invite our readers to believe what a judge says about law, or what an educator says about education. This approach appeals to our reader’s ethical sense: he or she believes these people know the facts and tell the truth.
Fright: A frightened reader is an interested reader. Frighten a reader only with facts that really are scary (such as the number of times computer error nearly launched a Third World War).
Climax: After a good introduction, start with your least dramatic point, then progress upward to your strongest.
Taken from The Act of Writing.
ORGANIZATION
Introduction
- should grab the reader’s attention
- should include a thesis statement that states a clear argumentative position and informs the reader of the key points in the composition
Body
- should include at least three key points
- the three reason paragraphs should each start with a topic sentence
- each reason should be supported with facts, expert opinions, quotations, and/or specific examples
- should address the reader’s concerns, counterclaims, and/or biases
- ideas should be organized to flow logically
- transitions should be used to connect all paragraphs and help ideas flow smoothly
Conclusion
- should remind the reader of the main idea and key points
- essay should end with a call to action
Remember…
- grammar and spelling count
- a variety of sentence patterns should be used.
English 11 students will then read and discuss “Nice Place to Visit” by Russell Baker.
English 10 students will begin to look at one of the two pieces for the synthesis section of the exam: the poem “Boy with His Hair Cut Short” by Muriel Rukeyser.